A Systematic Review of Mindfulness-Based School Interventions with Early Adolescents

Систематический обзор школьных вмешательств на основе практик осознанности для учащихся раннего подросткового возраста
Yoon‐Suk Hwang, Phillipa McKeering
2018-07-18

early adolescentsevidence-based practicemindfulness-based school interventionsstudent well-beingsystematic review
Recent research on mindfulness-based interventions (MBIs) in schools have reported effect differences across age groups of students, with early adolescent students reporting the least effect. Existing reviews, however, include students across all age ranges and largely concern intervention effects and their contributors. The exclusion of qualitative data exploring students’ experiences of learning and practising mindfulness omits valuable information that could be used to better inform implementation of MBIs. The lack of quality critique employed in the existing reviews necessitates a new review. A search carried out in nine electronic databases resulted in an initial selection of 1571 records, from which 13 papers emerged that met all inclusion criteria. The review found positive improvements reported in well-being measures in 11 of the 13 papers examined across both quantitative and qualitative data that provide support for mindfulness as a well-being school preventative program with this age group. A quality analysis critique of each paper demonstrated methodological strengths and limitations of existing MBI studies for early adolescent students, which inform ongoing conversations about whether and how MBIs meet the criteria of evidence-based practice (EBP) as an effective educational program. Findings are discussed for future research and education considerations are reviewed for educational professionals who aim to support early adolescents through the implementation of MBIs at school.
1
A systematic search across nine databases identified 13 eligible studies from 1,571 records on school-based mindfulness interventions for early adolescents.
2
Eleven of the 13 studies reported positive improvements in student well-being using quantitative and qualitative evidence.
3
Including qualitative evidence captured early adolescents’ experiences of learning and practising mindfulness, providing implementation-relevant insights absent from many previous reviews.
4
Quality appraisal identified methodological strengths and limitations across existing studies, leaving questions about whether MBIs meet evidence-based-practice standards for effective educational programs.
5
The findings support mindfulness-based interventions as potentially beneficial school-based preventive programs for early adolescents, despite this age group showing weaker effects in prior research.

mindfulness-based school interventions for early adolescent students

reported effects on well-being, students’ experiences of learning and practising mindfulness, and methodological quality of the interventions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2018-07-18
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
172
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Yoon‐Suk Hwang
Phillipa McKeering
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%