Methane slip and other emissions from newbuild LNG engine under real-world operation of a state-of-the art cruise ship

Утечка метана и другие выбросы нового судового СПГ-двигателя в реальных условиях эксплуатации современного круизного судна
Kati Lehtoranta, Niina Kuittinen, Hannu Vesala, P. Koponen
2024-08-01

LNG marine enginedual-fuel enginegreenhouse gas emissionsmethane slipparticle emissions
Liquefied natural gas (LNG) use as shipping fuel has increased in recent years. While LNG results in lower carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions as well as benefits in terms of air pollutants, the slip of unburned methane, the main component of LNG, has remained a concern. In this study, methane together with other climate warming agents, CO2 and black carbon (BC), as well as other emission compounds were characterized from 4-stroke low-pressure dual fuel engine on-board a newly build cruise ship utilizing LNG as well as marine gas oil (MGO). The brake specific methane slip was found to vary according to engine load, being 2.3–3.0 g/kWh at 54–80% loads, but increasing to 10 g/kWh at 25% load and 21 g/kWh at 12% load. The LNG combustion also resulted in higher formaldehyde emissions compared to MGO, but reduction in formaldehyde levels was observed over the SCR catalyst present in the exhaust line of the dual-fuel engine, without urea injection, suggesting it may provide a pathway for formaldehyde mitigation. In terms of particle emissions, LNG use reduced particle mass (PM) by 87–93% and BC by 94–99% compared to MGO combustion. Non-volatile particle number above 23 nm (PNnv,>23nm) and 10 nm (PNnv,>10nm) were reduced by 88–97% and 97–99%, except at lowest engine load where PNnv,>10nm increased by 26% compared to MGO utilization. When total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions including CO2 and BC were considered, LNG use resulted in 13–15% lower GHG at high loads, but the benefit was undermined by the escaping methane at low load conditions. Following the engine activity profile during 8-months of vessel operation on the Mediterranean suggested, however, that in a diesel-electric cruise ship, low load conditions are used mainly during arrivals and departures from harbors, as the engine was operated at loads above 40% for 90% of the operation time. Weighted emission factor, representing the actual engine operation, resulted in methane slip of 2.8 g/kWh or 1.7% of the fuel use, which is below the value considered in the FuelEU Maritime. The results suggest that load specific methane slip, together with engine load profile should be considered when evaluating methane slip on vessel or fleet level.
1
Brake-specific methane slip from the low-pressure dual-fuel engine increased sharply at low load, from 2.3–3.0 g/kWh at 54–80% load to 21 g/kWh at 12% load.
2
Compared with MGO, LNG reduced particle mass by 87–93%, black carbon by 94–99%, and most non-volatile particle number metrics by 88–99%.
3
During eight months of operation, the engine operated above 40% load for 90% of the time; operation-weighted methane slip was 2.8 g/kWh, equivalent to 1.7% of fuel use.
4
Including CO2 and black carbon, LNG lowered total greenhouse-gas emissions by 13–15% at high loads, but methane slip undermined benefits at low loads.
5
LNG combustion produced higher formaldehyde emissions than MGO, while the installed SCR catalyst reduced formaldehyde without urea injection.

A 4-stroke low-pressure dual-fuel LNG/MGO engine on board a newly built cruise ship operated under real-world conditions

Methane slip and climate-warming, gaseous, and particle emissions as functions of engine load and fuel use, including the emission-mitigation effect of the SCR catalyst

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-08-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
24
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Kati Lehtoranta
Niina Kuittinen
Hannu Vesala
P. Koponen
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%