Measuring Methane Slip from LNG Engines with Different Devices

Измерение проскока метана из двигателей, работающих на СПГ, с помощью различных приборов
Kati Lehtoranta, Niina Kuittinen, Hannu Vesala, Niklas Flygare, Anni-Rosa Apilainen
2025-04-30

LNG enginesflame ionization detectormethane abatement catalystmethane measurementmethane slip
When using liquefied natural gas (LNG) as fuel for shipping, the sulphur emissions are negligible and low NOx and particle emissions can be reached together with lower CO2 emissions compared to diesel-based fuels. The drawback of LNG usage is the unburned fuel, i.e., methane can be found in the exhaust. Reliable emission detection and quantification will play a key role, as methane is also becoming regulated. In this study, different methods to measure methane are studied in the engine laboratory and on board with state-of-the-art engines. Four different measurement methods are found to give similar methane results with few exceptions. Measurements performed downstream of the methane abatement catalyst show that all instruments could detect the methane conversion efficiency to be above 95%. Comparing results from onboard studies to earlier published onboard studies with similar engines indicate that the engine (46 DF) behaved rather similarly, and the measurements carried out at different occasions on board by different devices and parties gave similar results. To measure total hydrocarbons, a flame ionization detector (FID) has generally been the accepted method (e.g., in NOx Technical Code). Based on this study, other methods as reliable as FID for methane measurement exist and these methods can also be utilized on board.
1
Downstream methane-abatement catalysts, all instruments detected methane conversion efficiencies exceeding 95%.
2
Four methane measurement methods produced similar results in engine-laboratory and onboard tests, with only a few exceptions.
3
Methods other than the conventionally accepted flame ionization detector can measure methane reliably and can be used onboard ships.
4
Repeated onboard measurements by different devices and parties showed comparable results for the 46 DF engine, consistent with earlier studies.

Methane emissions (unburned methane in the exhaust) from LNG-fueled marine engines

The reliability and comparability of different methods for measuring methane emissions and methane-conversion efficiency

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-04-30
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
21
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Kati Lehtoranta
Niina Kuittinen
Hannu Vesala
Niklas Flygare
Anni-Rosa Apilainen
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%