Field Performance of New Methane Detection Technologies: Results from the Alberta Methane Field Challenge

Полевые характеристики новых технологий обнаружения метана: результаты полевых испытаний Alberta Methane Field Challenge
Chris H. Hugenholtz, Devyani Singh, Arvind Pawan Ravikumar, Brenna Barlow, Wes Funk, Cooper Robinson
2021-05-28

Alberta Methane Field Challengedrone-based technologiesintermittent tank emissionsmethane emissions detectionoptical gas imaging
Emerging methane technologies promise rapid and cost-effective methods to measure and monitor methane emissions. Here, we present results from the Alberta Methane Field Challenge – the first large-scale, concurrent field trial of eleven alternative methane emissions detection and quantification technologies at operating oil and gas sites. We evaluate new technologies by comparing their performance with conventional optical gas imaging survey. Overall, technologies are effective at detecting methane emissions, with 8 out of 11 technologies achieving an effectiveness of approximately 80%. Importantly, results highlight the key differences in technology performance between those observed at controlled release tests versus those in field conditions. Intermittent emissions from tanks substantially affects detection and site-level quantification estimates and should be independently monitored while assessing technology performance. In this study, all technologies improved their effectiveness in detecting tank emissions when intermittency was considered. Truck- and plane-based systems have clear advantages in survey speed over other technologies, but their use as effective screening technologies to identify high-emitting sites rests on their quantification effectiveness. Drone-based technologies demonstrated higher effectiveness than other technologies in identifying quantification rank compared to baseline OGI-based survey. Overall, quantification under in-field conditions is affected by several exogenous factors such as temporal variation in emissions and changing environmental conditions. We recommend that assessment studies of new methane detection technologies at oil and gas facilities include comprehensive, continuous, and redundant emissions measurement.
1
Eight of eleven technologies achieved approximately 80% effectiveness in detecting methane emissions, demonstrating generally strong detection capability.
2
In-field quantification was affected by temporal emission variability and changing environmental conditions, supporting comprehensive, continuous, and redundant measurement in technology assessments.
3
Intermittent tank emissions substantially influenced detection and site-level quantification; accounting for intermittency improved every technology’s tank-emission detection effectiveness.
4
Technology performance differed substantially between controlled-release tests and real field conditions, indicating that laboratory results may not predict operational effectiveness.
5
The Alberta Methane Field Challenge was the first large-scale concurrent field trial comparing eleven alternative methane technologies at operating oil and gas sites.
6
Truck- and plane-based systems offered clear survey-speed advantages, while drone-based technologies most effectively identified emission-quantification rankings relative to baseline optical gas imaging.

Alternative methane emissions detection and quantification technologies deployed at operating oil and gas sites

Field performance, detection effectiveness, survey speed, and site-level quantification accuracy under intermittent emissions and changing environmental conditions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-05-28
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
30
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Chris H. Hugenholtz
Devyani Singh
Arvind Pawan Ravikumar
Brenna Barlow
Wes Funk
Cooper Robinson
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%