Teachers and Generative AI: A Systematic Review of Adoption, Competence, Professional Development, and Socio-Technical Experiences

Учителя и генеративный искусственный интеллект: систематический обзор внедрения, компетентности, профессионального развития и социотехнического опыта
Sara Ayubian, Génesis Aguilar Chávez, Ernestina Wiafe, Vajiheh Shahsavari, Nelofar Khamisani, Noor Us Subah Quidwai, Dillon Simmons, Ambyr Rios, Farhan Sadique, J. Spencer Clark
2026-09-14

AI literacyGenerative AI in teachingSocio-technical conditionsSystematic reviewTPACK framework
Generative artificial intelligence (AI) has rapidly become integrated into teaching, yet evidence on how teachers actually adopt, experience, and implement it remains fragmented. This systematic review synthesizes 105 peer-reviewed empirical studies published since 2023, identified through a PRISMA-guided search of three leading educational technology journals indexed in Scopus and Web of Science. The findings show pronounced geographical disparities: research is concentrated in China, Turkey, the United States, and Spain, while Africa and Oceania are markedly underrepresented, skewing the evidence base toward high-resource systems. Across studies, AI literacy, pedagogical knowledge, and self-efficacy, often theorized through the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) framework, are the strongest predictors of effective integration. Adoption depends less on technological access than on socio-technical conditions: institutional support, leadership, professional development, trust, and teacher autonomy. Most studies use cross-sectional self-reports that capture intention rather than practice, leaving classroom implementation, longitudinal change, and equity barriers underexamined. This study argues that effective integration requires aligning technological, human, and organizational systems and outlines an agenda for context-sensitive, practice-oriented research.
1
AI literacy, pedagogical knowledge, and self-efficacy are the strongest reported predictors of effective generative AI integration, often framed through TPACK.
2
Adoption depends more on institutional support, leadership, professional development, trust, and teacher autonomy than on technological access alone.
3
Evidence is limited by predominantly cross-sectional self-reports, leaving classroom implementation, longitudinal change, and equity barriers underexamined.
4
Research is geographically concentrated in China, Turkey, the United States, and Spain, while Africa and Oceania are markedly underrepresented.
5
The systematic review synthesizes 105 peer-reviewed empirical studies on teachers’ generative AI adoption, competence, professional development, and socio-technical experiences.

Teachers’ integration and use of generative AI in teaching

Teachers’ adoption, AI literacy, pedagogical competence, self-efficacy, professional development, and socio-technical conditions shaping effective classroom implementation of generative AI

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-09-14
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
0
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Sara Ayubian
Génesis Aguilar Chávez
Ernestina Wiafe
Vajiheh Shahsavari
Nelofar Khamisani
Noor Us Subah Quidwai
Dillon Simmons
Ambyr Rios
Farhan Sadique
J. Spencer Clark
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%