Socializing Virtue Epistemology

Социализация эпистемологии добродетели
Dominik Jarczewski, Wayne D. Riggs
2025-03-27

epistemic individualismepistemic outsourcingvirtue epistemologyvirtue reliabilismvirtue responsibilism
Abstract In recent years, virtue epistemology has been criticized for its individualism. Correspondingly, some attempts have been made to make it more social. However, there is some confusion about what it means for virtue epistemology to be individualistic, and how it should be socialized in the face of this. The current paper proposes a systematic answer to these questions. We distinguish elements of theories of virtue that might give rise to different forms of individualism: “subject individualism,” “faculty/trait individualism,” and “value individualism.” Then we show what specific challenges these elements might pose for virtue reliabilism and responsibilism. We focus on two challenges: the epistemic value of other-regarding intellectual virtues, and the problem of “epistemic outsourcing.” In both cases, we identify and evaluate possible strategies for socializing these elements of virtue epistemology.
1
For both challenges, the paper identifies and evaluates strategies for socializing virtue epistemology.
2
It systematically analyzes how these forms of individualism create distinct challenges for virtue reliabilist and responsibilist theories.
3
The analysis focuses on the epistemic value of other-regarding intellectual virtues and the problem of epistemic outsourcing.
4
The paper argues that socializing virtue epistemology requires clarifying which individualistic element is at issue and tailoring the response accordingly.
5
The paper distinguishes three forms of individualism in virtue epistemology: subject individualism, faculty/trait individualism, and value individualism.

virtue epistemology, particularly virtue reliabilism and responsibilism

forms of individualism in virtue epistemology and strategies for socializing them, focusing on the epistemic value of other-regarding intellectual virtues and epistemic outsourcing

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-03-27
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Dominik Jarczewski
Wayne D. Riggs
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%