Get ready for agile methods, with care
Будьте готовы к гибким методам, но проявляйте осторожность
2002-01-01
SCID: 54.1/n7przcxp
Discuss with AI
agile software developmentchange responsivenessplan-driven methodsplanning spectrumsoftware development methods
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Although many of their advocates consider the agile and plan-driven software development methods polar opposites, synthesizing the two can provide developers with a comprehensive spectrum of tools and options. Real-world examples argue for and against agile methods. Responding to change has been cited as the critical technical success factor in the Internet browser battle between Microsoft and Netscape. But overresponding to change has been cited as the source of many software disasters, such as the $3 billion overrun of the US Federal Aviation Administration's Advanced Automation System for national air traffic control. The author believes that both agile and plan-driven approaches have a responsible center and overinterpreting radical fringes. Agile and plan-driven methods both form part of the planning spectrum. Thus, while each approach has a home ground within which it performs very well, and much better than the other, a combined approach is feasible and preferable in some circumstances.
Key Findings
1
Agile and plan-driven software development are not true opposites; they represent complementary points on a broader planning spectrum.
2
Combining agile and plan-driven practices can provide developers with a more comprehensive set of tools and options.
3
Each approach has a domain where it performs particularly well, making a combined strategy preferable under some project circumstances.
4
Responding rapidly to change contributed to Microsoft’s success in the browser competition, while excessive responsiveness contributed to the FAA system’s $3 billion overrun.
5
The paper cautions against interpreting the radical extremes of either agile or plan-driven methods as representative of their responsible applications.
Research Object
agile and plan-driven software development methods
Research Subject
the feasibility and circumstances for combining agile and plan-driven approaches across the software development planning spectrum
Publication Details
Publication Date
2002-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
934
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest