Polycentric Governing and Polycentric Governance

Полицентричное управление и полицентричное руководство
Andreas Thiel
2023-05-25

New Institutional Economicscollective goodsinstitutional processesmulti-scalar governancepolycentric governance
Abstract Existing literature has tended to define polycentric governance in the sense developed by the Bloomington School of Political Economy. In contrast, this chapter promotes polycentricity as a lens for analysing governance from an institutionalist perspective. Such an approach can be applied locally (e.g. to metropolitan, water, and landscape governance) as well as globally (e.g. to transnational value chains, marine, or migration governance). Under different names numerous analytical approaches that share the working assumptions of New Institutional Economics work on this basis. The lens of polycentric governance allows one to bring together multiple actors engaged in the provision and consumption of collective goods. The approach analyses the interplay of multiple interdependent but autonomous individual and collective, public, private, and civil society actors operating on and across different scales. Research on polycentric governance wonders to what extent ‘order’ or ‘coherence’ emerges out of these multi-actor multi-scalar dynamics and how this mode of organization fares in terms of other performance criteria such as accountability, effectiveness, equity, and sustainability. ‘Techniques’ from the perspective of polycentric governance relate to institutional processes. ‘Power’ is in this approach conceptualized as the capacity to shape the institutions of governance. ‘Legitimacy’ is conferred upon polycentric governance by citizens and consumers. As a major weakness, this approach has little eye for un-institutionalized politics.
1
It investigates whether order or coherence emerges from multi-actor, multi-scalar dynamics and evaluates accountability, effectiveness, equity, and sustainability.
2
Polycentric governance can analyze local and global arrangements, including metropolitan, water, landscape, marine, migration, and transnational value-chain governance.
3
The approach conceptualizes power as the capacity to shape governance institutions and legitimacy as conferred by citizens and consumers, but insufficiently addresses uninstitutionalized politics.
4
The chapter reframes polycentric governance as an institutionalist analytical lens, extending beyond the Bloomington School’s definition.
5
The framework examines interactions among interdependent yet autonomous public, private, and civil-society actors operating across multiple scales.

polycentric governance systems involving multiple interdependent but autonomous public, private, and civil-society actors operating across scales

the emergence of order and coherence, and performance in terms of accountability, effectiveness, equity, and sustainability in multi-actor, multi-scalar governance

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-05-25
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
33
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Andreas Thiel
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%