The art of referencing

Искусство цитирования
Monideepa Tarafdar, Robert M. Davison
2020-04-17

H-indexcitation manipulationpeer review processresearch ethicsself-citation
Earlier this year, we were startled to read that one of the world's most highly cited biophysicists had repeatedly manipulated “the peer review process to amass citations to his own work” (Van Noorden, 2020). Over a period of many years, this individual had asked authors of papers that he was handling as editor to cite significant numbers of his own published articles. Apparently, these authors did what they were asked to do. On some occasions it appears that they also added him as a co-author. Our first reaction was that this sort of brazen behaviour was entirely outside not only our experience but also our imagination. On more deliberate reflection, we decided that while this particular behaviour may not be common, it is not impossible that authors face situations where they are asked to add references to articles written by reviewers or editors. For example, one of us, early on in our career was asked by an editor to add 6 specific articles to their reference list, each written by the editor or his students. What should an author do? Referencing another's work is our written acknowledgement that it has inspired or provoked us. It should, therefore be a simple and pleasant matter. How hard can it be to say: “Thank you, that helped!”? The reality is more nuanced. Referencing leads to citations and hence to a higher “H Index” and i10 Index, numbers that most scholars believe reflects their impact/influence on other researchers and the discipline (cf. Davison & Bjørn-Andersen, 2019). The pressure to be cited is immense, and early career academics may not be aware of the ethical aspects of adding references at the request of an editor or reviewer. In the paragraphs below, we address a number of questions associated with referencing that we have come across in discussions with colleagues and authors, and that we think are important. As we tackle the key issues for each question, we provide clear indicators of what we believe is good practice. Q1: Is it reasonable for reviewers and/or editors to ask authors to cite specific articles? Yes. It is reasonable for reviewers and editors to suggest that an area of literature needs to be covered; they may also point out selected articles with which the authors should be familiar. If these are also articles that are written by the reviewers/editors themselves, then the latter need to proceed with caution, in part so as not to violate the blindness of the review process, in part so as not to (even unintentionally) abuse their privileged position as a gatekeeper. In particular, they should always be clear that acceptance of a paper is not conditional upon the inclusion of one or more specific articles, least of all those written by themselves. Referencing should never be coercive. Q2: What kind of referencing tone should I adopt? First, authors should cite articles on the basis of intellectual relevance. Second, they should avoid obsequiousness in their tone while referencing. Obsequiousness may be an unintended occurrence, perhaps due to lack of understanding of the appropriate tone that should be adopted, particularly in submissions to special issues where the identity of guest editors is known. Third, authors should take care not to adopt a derisive or demeaning tone in their paper, for instance if they do not agree with other scholars or if their findings differ significantly from previous work. The tone should at all times be respectful, collegial and constructive. Indeed, it is good practice to make the referencing impersonal, that is, to refer to the work rather than to the author. Q3: Which literatures should I cite? Authors should consider carefully the matter of citing articles from the IS literature. We occasionally encounter submissions that make a contribution to knowledge in a domain that is relevant for the ISJ's readers, yet include almost no citations from the IS literature. Instead, they extensively cite the literature in other disciplines, such as Marketing, Economics, Psychology and Organisational Behaviour. While those may be entirely relevant, it raises a red flag for reviewers when no prior IS articles are worth citing. Normally, we expect submissions to contribute to an intellectual conversation in both the journal and the IS discipline, so there must be articles in that discipline that can be referred to, examined, built upon and critiqued. It is reasonable that many of the references might come from other disciplines if the research is inter-disciplinary (Tarafdar & Davison, 2018), yet there should also be some links to work in the IS discipline. If there are really no such articles, then the relevance of the submitted article to the journal/IS discipline will be closely examined and a reject decision is quite likely, on the grounds of poor fit. Q4: Can I cite my own work? Yes. But be careful with self-citations. Naturally you know your own work best and it is reasonable that you build on your own work as you move forward. In new submissions, it is acceptable to write about yourself in the third person, so as to avoid saying “in my previous work”, thereby citing yourself anonymously. Alternatively, you can identify your prior work as Anonymous until the review process is complete, though you should realise that it is easy to find the author of a work on the internet in digital repositories or conference proceedings for example, given a title. If you self-cite excessively then this may give the impression that you are uninterested in or unaware of the work of others. You should not be surprised, then, if reviewers suggest other sources to consider. Q5: How should I choose which papers to cite? Editors and reviewers will expect that you have read what you cite. That is perhaps the best way to assess whether the reference is of robust quality and reliability or is questionable. Not all citations are equal! It is important to refer correctly to the concepts you reference, in both nomenclature and meaning.* They also expect that each article you cite is relevant to your paper. For example, you should not automatically and reflexively cite an article on a particular topic if it is not actually relevant to your work, just because the majority of papers on that topic do so. Further, the inappropriate citing of references, for example, citing supposedly important or influential authors and hoping that will help in some way or other, will be construed by readers as a form of name-dropping. This is best avoided. Editors are sensitive to this and will not be impressed. Having 2 to 3 citations is usually sufficient to illustrate a single point. If you want to include more, that is fine, but be aware that you may be challenged on their relevance and necessity. The number of citations supporting a statement is not necessarily evidence of the latter's scholarly or conceptual fidelity. Avoid gobs of references! For example, if you really want to cite, say, six articles in one sentence, then consider citing each one (or smaller groups) in support of a separate point, across several sentences. Some journals limit the number of articles that submissions are allowed to cite. This means that you should select the most important ones, that is, those that support your key arguments. In a related vein, references need to be comprehensive: you should not omit sources intentionally. You should also cite across a range of journals, not exclusively from just one or two. Q6: Can I cite from sources outside published journal issues and conference proceedings? Yes. But references need to be accessible. If you want to cite newspaper articles, magazine articles, white papers, etc. please provide a correct and working URL where the article can be found. Please do not cite unpublished papers unless they are either in a working paper repository such as the SSRN or have been through a review process and are forthcoming, in which case there is probably an Early Online version with a DOI that can be cited. It is fine to include articles written in other languages, but please translate their titles. Q7: Does citation accuracy matter or will readers figure it out anyway? References need to be accurate, which means that you must get all the details correct: authors, title, journal/conference name, volume, issue, pages, publisher and place of publication for books, location for conference, date and URL where appropriate. Author names are easy to get wrong especially if you are not familiar with the language. For example, first and last names might be switched and extra letters may be interpolated. Formatting and correct attributions, although easy enough with referencing software such as Endnote, should be checked not least because Endnote will perpetuate your entry errors with remarkable persistence. For example, we often see papers cited as “forthcoming” when they have already been published. Sloppy references may suggest to readers that that you are not really familiar with the work, that you copied the reference from somewhere, that you do not really care about accuracy or worse that you have not read the article that you cite. Q8: How old or new should citations be? References need to be up to date. Older literature is important, but readers like to know what the contemporary literature is in a given area (or, if the area is new, then related areas), and we expect that you will review this. Making sure you cover the last 5 years is (usually, but not always) a good benchmark for contemporaneousness. Q9: Do I need to cite papers from the journal I submit my paper to? References often provide unintentional clues to a submission's provenance! It is fine (and necessary) to re-submit rejected submissions to other journals, though you should also revise the paper before doing so. However, it is sensible to revisit the reference list and ensure that it accurately situates the submission in the intellectual conversation to which you are contributing in the next journal. Some journals explicitly ask authors to cite their papers; it is good practice to check a journal's “Instructions for Authors” webpages for such information. In our experience, while egregiously unethical behaviour with respect to referencing does occur from time to time, it is not that common. Instead, it is more often the case that authors are careless with their referencing. However, this does not diminish the importance of mindfulness and vigilance on part of reviewers, editors and authors, to get it right. Referencing is our chance to recognise those on whose shoulders we stand, our way of enacting our community's intellectual esprit-de-corps, our way of saying to colleagues we do not personally know and may never meet, “your work matters!”. This editorial is a call to each one of us to practice the art of referencing with care, honesty and vigour. This commentary section was authored by Monideepa Tarafdar and Robert M Davison. In this fifth issue of 2020, we present four papers. In the first paper, Yazdanmehr, Wang, and Yang (2020) propose a social contingency model in which a rules-oriented ethical climate at the organizational level and susceptibility to interpersonal influence at the individual level interact with both command-and-control and self-regulatory approaches to affect Information Security Policy (ISP) compliance. The results of this study show that both rules-oriented ethical climate and susceptibility to interpersonal influence weaken the effects of command-and-control and self-regulatory approaches on ISP compliance. This research will be of interest to both academics and practitioners as it is in line with the burgeoning attention to the role of social psychology in understanding the motivation behind employee ISP compliance. It advances the understanding of why command-and-control and/or self-regulatory approaches affect ISP compliance in some situations but not in others. In the second paper, Nishant and Ravishankar (2020) propose qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) as a novel method to harness unstructured data sets such as publicly available reports and news articles. They draw on an empirical study of green IS to showcase the potential of QCA to harness large unstructured qualitative material and generate more in-depth insights about emerging IS phenomena. They discuss how QCA and conventional qualitative IS research can complement each other. They further demonstrate how qualitative IS research can combine typical qualitative coding techniques with a specific type of QCA, namely crisp-set QCA (csQCA). They also highlight how QCA can contribute to the data collection and analysis stages of qualitative IS research. In the third paper, Tan, Ondrus, Tan, and Oh (2020) examine the evolution of the digital transformation of business ecosystems in the context of the Korean popular music industry (K-pop). The authors reveal that digital technologies drive critical boundary practices and formative strategies that enable the development of business ecosystems. The paper also addresses the prior lack of theoretical examination into the digital transformation of business ecosystems. Practically, the authors shed light on important stratification mechanisms and account for the dynamic interactions within a network of companies to enhance creativity and provide value for members of its business ecosystem. Today, the K-pop business ecosystem includes performing artists, entertainment companies, the media, digital platforms and event management firms, generating over US$40 billion annually and attracting over 30 million fans worldwide. In the fourth paper, Liu, Du, Hong, Fan, and Wu (2020) consider the context of collaborative crowdsourcing communities for open innovation, where users generate and submit ideas as idea co-creators and firms later select and implement valuable ideas for new product development. Despite the popularity and success of these open innovation communities, relatively little is known about the factors that determine the implementation of the user-generated ideas. Drawing on research on individual creativity, the authors propose a conceptual model integrating users' previous experience, idea presentation characteristics and feedback valence to explain the likelihood of idea implementation. The authors find an inverted U-shaped relationship between users' past successful experience and the generation of implemented ideas. Furthermore, the length of ideas is positively associated with the likelihood of idea implementation. There is also an inverted U-shaped relationship between supporting evidence and idea implementation. Finally, the authors demonstrate the negative effect of positive feedback and the positive effect of negative feedback on idea implementation. This section, introducing the articles in this issue, was written by Robert Davison. We greatly appreciate feedback received from our colleagues on the first part of the editorial: Cynthia Beath, M Lynne Markus, Dan Robey, Paul Lowry, and David Hull.
1
Although extreme citation manipulation may be uncommon, authors can encounter requests to add irrelevant or self-serving references from editors or reviewers.
2
Citation manipulation can involve editors requesting authors to add substantial numbers of the editor’s or reviewer’s publications to reference lists.
3
In some reported cases, authors were apparently pressured not only to add citations but also to include the citation-seeking individual as a co-author.
4
The paper presents questions and proposed indicators of good practice to help authors navigate ethically problematic referencing requests.
5
The pressure to increase citations and bibliometric indicators such as the H-index and i10-index creates ethical risks, particularly for early-career academics.

Academic referencing and citation practices in scholarly publishing

Ethical and professional issues surrounding citation requests, citation manipulation, and good referencing practice

Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-04-17
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
10
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Monideepa Tarafdar
Robert M. Davison
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%