Affect and Autocracy: Emotions and Attitudes in Russia after Crimea

Аффект и автократия: эмоции и установки в России после Крыма
Samuel A. Greene, Graeme B. Robertson
2020-09-14

Crimea annexationautocratic legitimacyemotional orientationmodern authoritarianismrally around the flag
Our understanding of modern authoritarianism lacks a satisfying explanation for the genuine popularity of autocrats. While most of the literature on authoritarianism focuses on coercion, institutional manipulation, or clientelism, many contemporary autocrats clearly enjoy enthusiastic support even in times of economic stagnation or decline. We argue that part of the solution lies in unpacking the role of emotions in building support for rulers. Drawing on a unique panel survey conducted shortly before and after Russia’s annexation of Crimea, we discover that the resulting “rally” around the authoritarian flag involves much more than simply support for the leader or a simple increase in nationalism. Rather, we witness a broad shift in respondents’ emotional orientation. Driven by the shared experience of the Crimean “moment,” this shift improves people’s evaluation of their social, political, and economic surroundings in the present, the future—and even the past. The result is a new explanation of the nonmaterial means through which autocrats may succeed in bolstering their legitimacy.
1
A unique panel survey conducted before and after Crimea’s annexation shows a broad emotional rally around Russia’s authoritarian regime.
2
Emotional experiences can provide autocrats with nonmaterial means of strengthening legitimacy, even amid economic stagnation or decline.
3
The post-Crimea rally involved more than increased leader support or nationalism; respondents’ overall emotional orientation shifted substantially.
4
The shared experience of the Crimean “moment” improved evaluations of social, political, and economic conditions in the present, future, and past.
5
The study explains autocratic popularity partly through emotions, complementing coercion, institutional manipulation, and clientelism-based accounts.

Russian respondents and their attitudes and emotions following Russia’s annexation of Crimea

The shift in emotional orientation and its effects on evaluations of the social, political, and economic environment and support for authoritarian leadership

Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-09-14
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
45
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Samuel A. Greene
Graeme B. Robertson
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%