The ``Who", ``What", and ``How" of Responsible AI Governance: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of (Actor, Stage)-Specific Tools
«Кто», «что» и «как» в управлении ответственным ИИ: систематический обзор и метаанализ инструментов, специфичных для пар «актор — этап»
2025-06-23
SCID: 54.1/smjqdffe
Discuss with AI
AI governance toolsAI lifecycleMeta-analysisResponsible AI governanceSystematic review
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The implementation of responsible Artificial Intelligence (AI) in an organization is inherently complex due to the involvement of multiple stakeholders, each with their unique set of goals and responsibilities across the entire AI lifecycle.These responsibilities are often ambiguously defined and assigned, leading to confusion, miscommunication, and inefficiencies.Even when responsibilities are clearly defined and assigned to specific roles, the corresponding AI actors lack effective tools to support their execution.Toward closing these gaps, we present a systematic review and comprehensive meta-analysis of the current state of responsible AI tools, focusing on their alignment with specific stakeholder roles and their responsibilities in various AI lifecycle stages.We categorize over 220 tools according to AI actors and stages they address.Our findings reveal significant imbalances across the stakeholder roles and lifecycle stages addressed.The vast majority of available tools have been created to support AI designers and developers specifically during data-centric and statistical modeling stages while neglecting other roles such as organizational leaders, deployers, end-users, and impacted communities, and stages such as value proposition and deployment.This uneven distribution highlights critical gaps that currently exist in responsible AI governance research and practice.Our analysis reveals that despite the myriad of frameworks and tools for responsible AI, it remains unclear who within an organization and when in the AI lifecycle a tool applies.Furthermore, existing tools are rarely validated, leaving critical gaps in their usability and effectiveness.These gaps provide a starting point for researchers and practitioners to create more effective and holistic approaches to responsible AI development and governance.
Key Findings
1
Available tools are heavily concentrated on AI designers and developers during data-centric and statistical modeling stages.
2
Despite numerous frameworks and tools, it remains unclear which organizational actors should use specific tools and at what lifecycle stage.
3
Existing responsible AI tools are rarely validated, leaving their usability and effectiveness uncertain.
4
Organizational leaders, deployers, end-users, impacted communities, and value-proposition and deployment stages are substantially underserved.
5
The review categorizes over 220 responsible AI tools by stakeholder role and AI lifecycle stage.
Research Object
responsible AI governance tools across organizational stakeholder roles and AI lifecycle stages
Research Subject
the alignment, distribution, usability, and effectiveness of tools across AI actors’ responsibilities and lifecycle stages
Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-06-23
Journal
ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency (FAccT)
Publisher
Association for Computing Machinery
ISSN
Cited by
47
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai5
A Unified Approach to Interpreting Model Predictions2017
"Why Should I Trust You?": Explaining the Predictions of Any Classifier2016
From What to How: An Initial Review of Publicly Available AI Ethics Tools, Methods and Research to Translate Principles into Practices2019
Corporate digital responsibility2019
Applying the ethics of AI: a systematic review of tools for developing and assessing AI-based systems2024