Human-AI governance (HAIG): A trust-utility approach
Управление взаимодействием человека и искусственного интеллекта (HAIG): подход на основе доверия и полезности
2026-05-01
SCID: 54.1/t9dkacxn
Discuss with AI
Accountability-Capability ParadoxHuman-AI governanceadaptive trust thresholdsalgorithmic juriesnon-delegable core
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
This paper introduces the Human-AI Governance (HAIG) framework, contributing to the AI Governance (AIG) field by foregrounding the relational dynamics between human and AI actors rather than treating AI systems as objects of governance alone. Current categorical frameworks (e.g., ‘human-in-the-loop’ models) inadequately capture how AI systems evolve from ‘tools’ to ‘partners’, particularly as foundation models demonstrate emergent capabilities and multi-agent systems exhibit autonomous goal-setting behaviours. As systems are deployed across contexts, agency redistributes in complex patterns that are better represented as positions along continua rather than discrete categories. The HAIG framework operates across three levels: dimensions (Decision Authority, Process Autonomy, and Accountability Configuration), continua (continuous positional spectra along each dimension), and thresholds (critical points along the continua where governance requirements shift qualitatively). The framework's dimensional architecture is level-agnostic, applicable from individual deployment decisions and organisational governance through to sectorial comparison and national/international regulatory design. Unlike risk-based or principle-based approaches that treat governance primarily as a constraint on AI deployment, HAIG adopts a trust-utility orientation – reframing governance as the condition under which human-AI collaboration can realise its potential, calibrating oversight to specific relational contexts rather than predetermined categories. The analysis reveals how technical advances in self-supervision, reasoning authority, and distributed decision-making drive context-dependent and non-uniform evolution in trustworthiness conditions — with consequences for the trust attitudes of relevant stakeholders that existing categorical frameworks are ill-equipped to track. Case studies in healthcare and European regulation demonstrate how HAIG complements existing frameworks while offering a foundation for adaptive regulatory design that anticipates governance challenges before they emerge.
Key Findings
1
HAIG uses adaptive trust thresholds to preserve human comprehensibility and control instead of relying on recursive AI-monitoring-AI hierarchies.
2
It identifies an Accountability-Capability Paradox in which increasingly capable AI systems become harder for humans to oversee meaningfully.
3
The Human-AI Governance (HAIG) framework models oversight across decision authority, process autonomy, and accountability configuration.
4
The paper introduces the non-delegable core: governance functions that must remain under human authority to preserve democratic legitimacy, regardless of AI capability.
5
The paper proposes institutional innovations, including AI audit courts and algorithmic juries, to support democratic hybrid governance in critical domains.
Research Object
Human-AI governance (HAIG) framework for governing increasingly autonomous and agentic AI systems
Research Subject
Trust-based allocation of decision authority, process autonomy, and accountability between humans and AI, including non-delegable governance functions and adaptive trust thresholds
Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-05-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
36
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai5
A survey on large language model based autonomous agents2024
Resistance to Medical Artificial Intelligence2019
Human–AI Interactions in Public Sector Decision Making: “Automation Bias” and “Selective Adherence” to Algorithmic Advice2020
Defining organizational AI governance2022
AI governance: themes, knowledge gaps and future agendas2023