Rationality, Power, Management and Symbols: Four Images of Regulatory Impact Assessment
Рациональность, власть, управление и символы: четыре образа оценки регулирующего воздействия
2009-09-29
SCID: 54.1/ta3rs3sy
Discuss with AI
better regulationpolitical control of bureaucracypublic management reformrational policy makingregulatory impact assessment
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Impact assessment is the pivotal instrument in the recent wave of regulatory reforms labeled ‘better regulation’. Although the economics of impact assessment has been the subject of a vast literature, less is known about its political properties. Within a comparative framework, this article provides conjectures on four images of impact assessment – that is, rational policy making, political control of the bureaucracy, public management reform, and symbolic action. Looking at six countries with a long experience of impact assessment and the European Union, the article first builds expectations about the diffusion of the images across countries, and then proceeds to measurement by using both objective and interpretative/subjective indicators. The findings seem to support the public management reform image – a conclusion that suggests further specifications about administrative traditions and change. Sweden and Denmark are not using impact assessment to foster instrumental rationality or increase the political control of bureaucracies and, together with the Netherlands, rank high on the symbolic action scale. The United States – and to a lesser extent Canada and the United Kingdom – have a multi-purpose approach to impact assessment. The case of the European Union defies prior expectations, showing much more usage than anticipated.
Key Findings
1
Comparative evidence from six countries and the European Union primarily supports the public management reform image of impact assessment.
2
Sweden and Denmark do not use impact assessment to promote instrumental rationality or strengthen political control over bureaucracies.
3
Sweden, Denmark, and the Netherlands score highly on the symbolic-action dimension of impact assessment.
4
The United States, and to a lesser extent Canada and the United Kingdom, employ impact assessment for multiple purposes; the European Union uses it more extensively than expected.
5
The article develops four political images of regulatory impact assessment: rational policymaking, bureaucratic control, public management reform, and symbolic action.
Research Object
regulatory impact assessment in national governments and the European Union
Research Subject
the political properties and competing institutional images of regulatory impact assessment, including rational policymaking, bureaucratic control, public management reform, and symbolic action
Publication Details
Publication Date
2009-09-29
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
69
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest