The many uses of regulatory impact assessment: A meta‐analysis of EU and UK cases

Многообразие применения оценки регулирующего воздействия: метаанализ практики ЕС и Великобритании
Claudio Maria Radaelli, Duncan Russel, Claire A. Dunlop, Martino Maggetti
2012-01-03

EU and UK case studiesbetter regulation movementmeta-analysispolicy instrumentsregulatory impact assessment
Abstract Research on regulation has crossed paths with the literature on policy instruments, showing that regulatory policy instruments contain cognitive and normative beliefs about policy. Thus, their usage stacks the deck in favor of one type of actor or one type of regulatory solution. In this article, we challenge the assumption that there is a predetermined relationship between ideas, regulatory policy instruments, and outcomes. We argue that different combinations of conditions lead to different outcomes, depending on how actors use the instrument. Empirically, we analyze 31 EU and UK case studies of regulatory impact assessment (RIA) – a regulatory policy instrument that has been pivotal in the so‐called better regulation movement. We distinguish four main usages of RIA, that is, political, instrumental, communicative, and perfunctory. We find that in our sample instrumental usage is not so rare and that the contrast between communicative and political usages is less stark than is commonly thought. In terms of policy recommendations, our analysis suggests that there may be different paths to desirable outcomes. Policymakers should therefore explore different combinations of conditions leading to the usages they deem desirable rather than arguing for a fixed menu of variables.
1
A meta-analysis of 31 EU and UK regulatory impact assessment cases identifies four usages: political, instrumental, communicative, and perfunctory.
2
Desirable regulatory outcomes can follow different combinations of conditions, so policymakers should avoid relying on a fixed menu of determinants.
3
Instrumental use of regulatory impact assessment is more common than previously assumed in the analyzed sample.
4
The distinction between communicative and political uses of regulatory impact assessment is less pronounced than commonly thought.
5
The study challenges the assumption that regulatory instruments have predetermined relationships with ideas, actor behavior, and policy outcomes.

regulatory impact assessment (RIA) as a regulatory policy instrument in EU and UK cases

the different usages of RIA—political, instrumental, communicative, and perfunctory—and their relationship to outcomes under varying conditions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2012-01-03
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
127
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Claudio Maria Radaelli
Duncan Russel
Claire A. Dunlop
Martino Maggetti
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%