A content analysis of research approaches in logistics research

Контент-анализ исследовательских подходов в исследованиях по логистике
Karen M. Spens, Gyöngyi Kovács
2006-06-01

abductive researchcontent analysishypothetico-deductive approachlogistics researchsurvey methods
Purpose Based on a framework developed by Kovács and Spens, this paper seeks to assess the use of the three different research approaches in logistics research; discuss the use of different research methods within the three research approaches; find and discuss applications of the abductive research approach to logistics problems. Design/methodology/approach Content analysis is used in order to categorize the different research approaches. While content analysis commonly uses smaller units such as paragraphs, sentences, words or characters, this study used entire articles as the unit of analysis. The scope of the review encompassed five years (1998‐2002) of articles in IJLM, IJPDLM and JBL. A total of 378 articles was reviewed and categorized. Findings The findings of the study corroborate earlier studies regarding the main research approach used in logistics. Published logistics research is hypothetico‐deductive, with a strong emphasis on using survey methods. Nevertheless, inductive as well as abductive research is gaining importance. However, most logistics articles do not explicitly discuss the research process, nor the approach used. Therefore, a call for more explicit statements of the research approach is suggested. Research limitations/implications The review of the articles is limited to three main journals in the field. A more comprehensive view of research approaches could be obtained by broadening the review to include also other types of research. Practical implications The paper provides a framework and guidelines to researchers for explicitly discussing the research approach used in logistics articles. Originality/value The paper provides an overview of the research approaches used in logistics research.
1
Hypothetico-deductive research is the dominant approach in logistics research, with strong reliance on survey methods.
2
Inductive and abductive approaches are gaining importance in logistics research, although abductive applications remain insufficiently explicit.
3
Most logistics articles do not explicitly state their research approach or describe the research process.
4
The study provides a framework and guidelines for explicitly reporting research approaches and identifies limited generalizability beyond the three reviewed journals.
5
The study reviewed and categorized 378 logistics research articles published from 1998–2002 across three leading journals.

published logistics research articles in three main logistics journals (IJLM, IJPDLM, and JBL) from 1998–2002

the prevalence and explicit use of hypothetico-deductive, inductive, and abductive research approaches and methods

Publication Details
Publication Date
2006-06-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Karen M. Spens
Gyöngyi Kovács
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%