How Ideas Spread: Whose Norms Matter? Norm Localization and Institutional Change in Asian Regionalism
Как распространяются идеи: чьи нормы имеют значение? Локализация норм и институциональные изменения в азиатском регионализме
2004-04-01
SCID: 54.1/xg9ge24t
Discuss with AI
ASEANAsian regionalisminstitutional changenorm diffusionnorm localization
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Questions about norm diffusion in world politics are not simply about whether and how ideas matter, but also which and whose ideas matter. Constructivist scholarship on norms tends to focus on “hard” cases of moral transformation in which “good” global norms prevail over the “bad” local beliefs and practices. But many local beliefs are themselves part of a legitimate normative order, which conditions the acceptance of foreign norms. Going beyond an existential notion of congruence, this article proposes a dynamic explanation of norm diffusion that describes how local agents reconstruct foreign norms to ensure the norms fit with the agents' cognitive priors and identities. Congruence building thus becomes key to acceptance. Localization, not wholesale acceptance or rejection, settles most cases of normative contestation. Comparing the impact of two transnational norms on the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), this article shows that the variation in the norms' acceptance, indicated by the changes they produced in the goals and institutional apparatuses of the regional group, could be explained by the differential ability of local agents to reconstruct the norms to ensure a better fit with prior local norms, and the potential of the localized norm to enhance the appeal of some of their prior beliefs and institutions.
Key Findings
1
In ASEAN, differences in transnational norm acceptance and institutional change reflect local agents’ varying ability to align norms with prior beliefs and institutions.
2
Local agents dynamically reconstruct foreign norms to fit existing cognitive priors and identities, making congruence building central to norm acceptance.
3
Localization, rather than wholesale acceptance or rejection, resolves most cases of normative contestation.
4
Localized norms gain influence when they reinforce the appeal of existing local beliefs and institutional arrangements.
5
Norm diffusion depends not only on whether ideas matter, but also on whose norms shape their acceptance.
Research Object
Norm diffusion and localization in ASEAN regionalism
Research Subject
How local agents reconstruct transnational norms to fit prior local norms, identities, beliefs, and institutions, thereby shaping norm acceptance and institutional change
Publication Details
Publication Date
2004-04-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
2352
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai2
Cited by3
Stigma Management in International Relations: Transgressive Identities, Norms, and Order in International Society2014
The dual transformation in development finance: western multilateral development banks and China in post-Soviet energy2021
Soft Balancing, Hedging, and Institutional Darwinism: The Economic-Security Nexus and East Asian Regionalism2010