Influence of mining rent on the efficiency of using natural potential: the paradox of plenty and its Russian specifics
Влияние горнодобывающей ренты на эффективность использования природного потенциала: парадокс изобилия и его российская специфика
2023-03-02
SCID: 54.1/y3bvmsm9
Discuss with AI
institutional factors (rent-oriented behavior)mining rentoil and gas dependenceparadox of plentyresource curse
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
The most powerful potential of Russia's natural resources is only partially realized, and determining the reasons for the insufficient efficiency of its use is a current research topic. The exploitation of mineral resources that bring mining rent (primarily oil and gas) gives rise to the so-called “paradox of plenty” (PP), which in some cases manifests itself as a significant slowdown in economic development. The purpose of the article is to clarify the signs, degree and forms of PP manifestation and related problems (“resource curse”, “oil curse”, etc.) in the Russian economy. Since the causes of these phenomena are usually associated with rent extraction and peculiarities of the institutional structure of the economy, the works of leading economists who support the theories of “rent-oriented behavior” and the role of public institutions in the process of the PP emergence were critically analyzed. To determine the signs and degree of PP manifestation and related problems, an analysis of determining the shares of oil and gas in the structure of exports, revenues from their sale in the federal budget, and oil and gas products in the structure of GDP, was made. It is concluded that there are no sufficient grounds for ascertaining clear signs of a “rent-oriented” Russian economy and a “resource curse”; important counteracting factors that refute the unambiguous conclusions about the high degree of PP impact on the Russian economy were identified. The author's interpretation of the role of public institutions, the factors of formation and forms of PP manifestation, the specifics of differential mining rent and its role in the formation of PP are proposed; options for solving problems generated by PP – directions for improving the tax system in the field of oil and gas, etc.; substantiation of the need to develop a strategic state program for diversifying the sectoral structure of the Russian economy; directions for adjusting economic policy in the field of oil and gas industry development, etc.
Key Findings
1
Analysis of oil and gas shares in exports, federal budget revenues, and GDP finds insufficient grounds to assert a strong 'rent-oriented' economy or definitive 'resource curse' in Russia.
2
Author proposes reinterpretation of public institutions' role, differential mining rent formation, and specific forms of PP manifestation in Russia.
3
Important counteracting factors exist that undermine conclusions about a high degree of PP impact on the Russian economy.
4
Mining rent from oil and gas can produce a 'paradox of plenty' (PP) that may slow economic development in some cases.
5
Policy recommendations include improving oil and gas taxation, creating a strategic state program to diversify the economy, and adjusting economic policy for the oil and gas sector.
6
Russia's natural resource potential is only partially realized, motivating analysis of causes of inefficient use.
Research Object
Mining rent from oil and gas exploitation in the Russian economy
Research Subject
Influence of mining rent on the efficiency of natural resource use and the manifestation/forms/degrees of the paradox of plenty (resource curse) including institutional factors and sectoral/economic impacts
Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-03-02
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
16
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest