A Meta-Analysis of Interventions to Decrease Disruptive Classroom Behavior in Public Education Settings

Мета-анализ вмешательств по снижению деструктивного поведения в классе в государственных образовательных учреждениях
Scott A. Stage, David R. Quiroz
1997-09-01

Interrupted Time Series Autocorrelation (ITSACORR)behavioral observationdisruptive classroom behaviormeta-analysissingle-subject studies
We conducted a meta-analysis of 99 studies that used interventions to decrease disruptive classroom behavior in public education settings. Due to the predominance of single-subject studies, we used the Interrupted Time Series Autocorrelation program (ITSACORR; Crosbie, 1993) which yielded a t statistic that was transformed into an effect size. A total of 223 effect sizes yielded a mean effect size of-.78, indicating that, on average, 78% of the treated students reduced their disruptive behavior compared to nontreated students. We found that studies using teacher rating scales were less likely to evidence reductions in disruptive classroom behaviors compared to studies using behavioral observation methodologies. We also found that students treated in self-contained classrooms were more likely to evidence a reduction in disruptive classroom behavior compared to students treated in regular classroom settings. With the exclusion of studies using teacher rating scales, comparison of treatment interventions showed no statistically reliable differences due to the large variability in the relative effectiveness for students treated. Overall, results indicate that interventions to reduce disruptive classroom behavior yield comparable results to other meta-analytic studies investigating the effectiveness of psychotherapy for children and adolescents. This indicates that there are efficacious treatments used in public education settings to to decrease disruptive classroom behaviors.
1
After excluding studies using teacher rating scales, no statistically reliable differences were found between types of treatment interventions, due to large variability in relative effectiveness.
2
Meta-analysis of 99 studies (223 effect sizes) found a mean effect size of -0.78, indicating on average 78% reduction in disruptive behavior for treated students versus nontreated students.
3
Overall effectiveness of interventions in public education settings for disruptive behavior is comparable to meta-analytic results for psychotherapy effectiveness with children and adolescents, indicating existence of efficacious treatments in schools.
4
Single-subject dominant literature analyzed via ITSACORR (Interrupted Time Series Autocorrelation) to convert t statistics into effect sizes for aggregation.
5
Students treated in self-contained classrooms showed greater reductions in disruptive classroom behavior compared to students treated in regular classroom settings.
6
Studies using teacher rating scales were less likely to show reductions in disruptive classroom behaviors than studies using behavioral observation methodologies.

Interventions to decrease disruptive classroom behavior in public education settings

Effectiveness (mean effect size, comparative effectiveness across measurement methods and classroom types) of those interventions in reducing disruptive classroom behavior

Publication Details
Publication Date
1997-09-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
348
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Scott A. Stage
David R. Quiroz
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%