Comparative analysis of fit, mechanical properties, and surface characteristics in subtractive- and additive-manufactured zirconia crowns

Сравнительный анализ прилегания, механических свойств и характеристик поверхности коронок из циркония, изготовленных вычитным и аддитивным методами
Ji‐Man Park, Ryan Jin‐Young Kim, Su-Min Cho, Alexis Ioannidis, Hye‐Min Chung
2025-08-01

additive manufacturing (AM)hardness (≥1200 HV)marginal fitmechanical propertiesshear bond strengthstereolithography (SLA) spreadingsubtractive manufacturing (SM)surface characteristicszirconia crowns
BACKGROUND: This study presents different zirconia additive manufacturing (AM) materials and technologies while assessing the fit, hardness, and shear bond strength of crowns produced by AM and subtractive manufacturing (SM) methods, as well as their surface characteristics. METHODS: Zirconia crowns were fabricated using a 5-axis SM and five AM approaches, including four digital light processing principles and one stereolithography (SLA) technique. Each method utilized varying slurry delivery and light-curing mechanisms. The replica technique measured marginal and internal gaps (axial, line angle, and occlusal) between the crowns and abutments. The Vickers hardness and shear bond strength of crowns bonded with resin cement were assessed. Surface characteristics were analyzed with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) post-printing and sandblasting. The fit, hardness, and shear bond strength of crowns were manufactured through AM and SM methods. Sixty crowns were fabricated (10 per group). Statistical analysis was conducted using one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Tukey post-hoc testing (α = 0.05). RESULTS: The marginal fits were 48.45 µm and 42.83 to 81.95 µm for the S and AM groups, respectively. Significant differences were observed between groups (< 0.001), although all measurements fell within the clinical acceptance range (120 µm). The Vickers hardness measurements revealed that the SM group had a hardness of 1473.87 HV, whereas those of the AM groups ranged from 1441.94 to 1532.53 HV, showing statistically significant differences (P < 0.001). Shear bond strength measurements displayed 7.97 MPa and 6.97 to 8.97 MPa for the SM and AM groups, respectively, with no significant differences between the groups. SEM analysis of the crown surfaces revealed agglomerated zirconia particles with various grooves after sandblasting. CONCLUSIONS: Zirconia crowns produced through the AM and SM methods demonstrated clinically acceptable marginal fit and ideal hardness exceeding 1200 HV. Some AM groups demonstrated higher hardness and shear bond strength than the SM group. The diverse physical and mechanical properties of various zirconia AM technologies suggest their selective use in specific clinical situations. Certain AM techniques, such as SLA spreading demonstrated comparable or even superior results to those of SM in terms of fit and hardness, indicating their potential as viable alternatives in clinical settings.
1
All tested zirconia crowns exhibited ideal hardness exceeding 1200 HV.
2
Different zirconia AM technologies displayed varied physical and mechanical properties, suggesting selective clinical use depending on technique.
3
SLA spreading AM technique achieved fit and hardness comparable to or better than SM, indicating it as a viable clinical alternative.
4
Some AM groups had higher hardness and higher shear bond strength than the SM group.
5
Zirconia crowns made by both additive manufacturing (AM) and subtractive manufacturing (SM) showed clinically acceptable marginal fit.

Zirconia dental crowns manufactured by subtractive manufacturing (SM) and various additive manufacturing (AM) technologies

Comparative fit, mechanical properties (hardness, shear bond strength), and surface characteristics of zirconia crowns produced by SM versus different AM techniques

Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-08-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
8
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ji‐Man Park
Ryan Jin‐Young Kim
Su-Min Cho
Alexis Ioannidis
Hye‐Min Chung
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%