Global citation inequality is on the rise

Глобальное неравенство в цитировании растёт
Mathias Wullum Nielsen, Jens Peter Andersen
2021-02-08

author-level citation analysiscitation concentrationcitation inequalityelite scientistsscientific collaboration
Citations are important building blocks for status and success in science. We used a linked dataset of more than 4 million authors and 26 million scientific papers to quantify trends in cumulative citation inequality and concentration at the author level. Our analysis, which spans 15 y and 118 scientific disciplines, suggests that a small stratum of elite scientists accrues increasing citation shares and that citation inequality is on the rise across the natural sciences, medical sciences, and agricultural sciences. The rise in citation concentration has coincided with a general inclination toward more collaboration. While increasing collaboration and full-count publication rates go hand in hand for the top 1% most cited, ordinary scientists are engaging in more and larger collaborations over time, but publishing slightly less. Moreover, fractionalized publication rates are generally on the decline, but the top 1% most cited have seen larger increases in coauthored papers and smaller relative decreases in fractional-count publication rates than scientists in the lower percentiles of the citation distribution. Taken together, these trends have enabled the top 1% to extend its share of fractional- and full-count publications and citations. Further analysis shows that top-cited scientists increasingly reside in high-ranking universities in western Europe and Australasia, while the United States has seen a slight decline in elite concentration. Our findings align with recent evidence suggesting intensified international competition and widening author-level disparities in science.
1
A small elite of scientists increasingly captures citation shares across the natural, medical, and agricultural sciences.
2
Growing citation concentration coincides with more collaboration: ordinary scientists collaborate more and publish slightly less, while the top 1% gains more coauthored output.
3
The top 1% most cited scientists have extended their shares of both fractional- and full-count publications and citations.
4
Top-cited scientists are increasingly concentrated in high-ranking universities in western Europe and Australasia, whereas elite concentration slightly declined in the United States.
5
Using data on over 4 million authors and 26 million papers across 118 disciplines and 15 years, the study finds rising author-level citation inequality.

Author-level citation distribution across scientific papers (global dataset of >4 million authors and 26 million papers)

Trends in author-level citation inequality and concentration, including their relationship with collaboration, publication counting, and the geographic and institutional distribution of top-cited scientists

Publication Details
Publication Date
2021-02-08
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
234
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Mathias Wullum Nielsen
Jens Peter Andersen
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%