New Conceptions of Thinking: From Ontology to Education

Новые представления о мышлении: от онтологии к образованию
David Perkins, Eileen Jay, Shari Tishman, David Perkins
1993-01-01

abstract conceptual structuresdispositions (thinking)enculturationgeneral processes viewlanguage of thinking
Current efforts both to conceptualize good thinking and to teach thinking are dominated by what might be called the general processes view, which holds that good thinking consists in a number of general cognitive processes supported by appropriate skills and strategies. This view suggests that thinking works top-down through the activation of general processes that access context-specific knowledge and call subprocesses. However, contemporary scholars in this issue and elsewhere have proposed constituents of good thinking quite different from processes, strategies, and skills—in effect a broader ontology of the kinds of things that figure in good thinking. We define three categories in this broadened ontology in addition to processes: the language of thinking, abstract conceptual structures, and dispositions. It is argued that these categories bring with them a less top-down view of how thinking works: Different constituents of thinking are activated by the particulars of an occasion of thinking and by one another in a process that might be termed coalescence. The greater range of constituents and the nature of coalescence call for a richer conception of teaching thinking. It is suggested that the notion of enculturation provides such a conception.
1
The authors propose a broader ontology of thinking that adds three constituent categories beyond processes: the language of thinking, abstract conceptual structures, and dispositions.
2
The dominant 'general processes' view defines good thinking as top-down activation of general cognitive processes, skills, and strategies.
3
The paper suggests enculturation as a promising instructional conception aligned with the broader ontology and coalescence view of thinking.
4
Thinking operates less top-down than the general processes view suggests; constituents are activated by particulars of an occasion and by one another in a 'coalescence' process.
5
This broadened ontology implies the need for a richer conception of teaching thinking beyond process-focused instruction.

Good thinking (the phenomena/constituents that constitute 'good thinking')

The ontology and constituents of good thinking—including processes, language of thinking, abstract conceptual structures, and dispositions—and how these constituents interact (coalescence) with implications for teaching/enculturation

Publication Details
Publication Date
1993-01-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
100
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
David Perkins
Eileen Jay
Shari Tishman
David Perkins
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%