Red and Processed Meats and Health Risks: How Strong Is the Evidence?
Красное и переработанное мясо и риски для здоровья: насколько убедительны доказательства?
2020-01-13
SCID: 54.1/a4as7tqm
Discuss with AI
GRADE criteriaNutriGRADEnutritional evidencered and processed meatstype 2 diabetes
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Prevailing dietary guidelines have widely recommended diets relatively low in red and processed meats and high in minimally processed plant foods for the prevention of chronic diseases. However, an ad hoc research group called the Nutritional Recommendations (NutriRECS) consortium recently issued "new dietary guidelines" encouraging individuals to continue their current meat consumption habits due to "low certainty" of the evidence, difficulty of altering meat eaters' habits and preferences, and the lack of need to consider environmental impacts of red meat consumption. These recommendations are not justified, in large part because of the flawed methodologies used to review and grade nutritional evidence. The evidence evaluation was largely based on the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) criteria, which are primarily designed to grade the strength of evidence for clinical interventions especially pharmacotherapy. However, the infeasibility for conducting large, long-term randomized clinical trials on most dietary, lifestyle, and environmental exposures makes the criteria inappropriate in these areas. A separate research group proposed a modified and validated system for rating the meta-evidence on nutritional studies (NutriGRADE) to address several limitations of the GRADE criteria. Applying NutriGRADE, the evidence on the positive association between red and processed meats and type 2 diabetes was rated to be of "high quality," while the evidence on the association between red and processed meats and mortality was rated to be of "moderate quality." Another important limitation is that inadequate attention was paid to what might be replacing red meat, be it plant-based proteins, refined carbohydrates, or other foods. In summary, the red/processed meat recommendations by NutriRECS suffer from important methodological limitations and involve misinterpretations of nutritional evidence. To improve human and planetary health, dietary guidelines should continue to emphasize dietary patterns low in red and processed meats and high in minimally processed plant foods such as fruits and vegetables, whole grains, nuts, and legumes.
Key Findings
1
Evaluations inadequately considered what foods replace red meat, including plant-based proteins, refined carbohydrates, or other alternatives.
2
GRADE criteria are inappropriate for many dietary, lifestyle, and environmental exposures because large, long-term randomized trials are generally infeasible.
3
NutriGRADE rated evidence linking red and processed meats with type 2 diabetes as high quality and evidence linking them with mortality as moderate quality.
4
NutriRECS recommendations to maintain current red and processed meat consumption are unjustified because their evidence-grading methodology is poorly suited to nutrition research.
5
The abstract concludes that NutriRECS recommendations contain important methodological limitations and misinterpret nutritional evidence, with implications for human and planetary health.
Research Object
Red and processed meat consumption
Research Subject
The strength and health implications of the evidence on associations with type 2 diabetes and mortality, including the effects of replacement foods
Publication Details
Publication Date
2020-01-13
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
169
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest