Selective Consolidation in AI Agent Research: A Co-Citation Analysis of Its Intellectual Structure and Relevance for Human–Computer Interaction

Избирательная консолидация исследований ИИ-агентов: анализ совместного цитирования их интеллектуальной структуры и значимости для взаимодействия человека и компьютера
José Torres-Pruñonosa, David López-López, Josep Maria Marco-Simó, Raúl Gómez Martínez, Ana Cruz-Suárez
2026-09-21

AI agent researchCiteSpaceco-citation analysishuman–agent interactionselective consolidation
Research on Artificial Intelligence (AI) agents has expanded rapidly across dis-ciplines, generating a diverse but fragmented body of knowledge. Despite the proliferation of domain-specific reviews, a field-level understanding of how AI agent research is intellectually structured and how it evolves over time remains limited, particularly from the perspective of human–computer interaction (HCI). This study aims to map the intellectual structure and temporal evolution of AI agent research and to identify the major conceptual streams shaping the devel-opment of the field. To achieve this, we conduct a co-citation analysis of AI agent publications indexed in the Web of Science. Using CiteSpace, the analysis identifies ten co-citation clusters that capture the main conceptual streams shaping AI agent research. The results show that the field is organized around multiple, partially connected research logics, includ-ing human–agent interaction, application-driven studies, organizational contexts, and governance-related concerns. An examination of citation bursts and intellec-tual turning points reveals that the field evolves through a process of selective consolidation, whereby a limited number of influential works periodically reshape research trajectories and establish dominant reference points. By uncovering the intellectual structure and dynamics of AI agent research, this study provides a field-level perspective that can support more cumulative and integrative scholarship. For the HCI community, the findings offer a struc-tured overview of the conceptual foundations informing the design, study, and evaluation of AI-driven interactive systems.
1
A Web of Science co-citation analysis using CiteSpace identifies ten major conceptual clusters structuring AI agent research.
2
AI agent research comprises multiple partially connected logics, including human–agent interaction, applications, organizational contexts, and governance concerns.
3
Citation bursts and intellectual turning points indicate selective consolidation, with influential works periodically reshaping research trajectories and establishing dominant reference points.
4
For HCI, the findings organize conceptual foundations relevant to designing, studying, and evaluating AI-driven interactive systems.
5
The study provides a field-level map of AI agent research that may support more cumulative and integrative scholarship.

AI agent research as represented by publications indexed in the Web of Science

The intellectual structure, temporal evolution, conceptual streams, and selective consolidation dynamics of AI agent research

Publication Details
Publication Date
2026-09-21
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
1
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
José Torres-Pruñonosa
David López-López
Josep Maria Marco-Simó
Raúl Gómez Martínez
Ana Cruz-Suárez
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%