Systematic Social Observation of Public Spaces: A New Look at Disorder in Urban Neighborhoods

Систематическое социальное наблюдение общественных пространств: новый взгляд на беспорядок в городских районах
Stephen W. Raudenbush, Robert J. Sampson
1999-11-01

public spacessocial disordersystematic social observationurban neighborhoods
American Journal of Sociology such as verbal harassment on the street, open solicitation for prostitution, public intoxication, and rowdy groups of young males in public.By physical disorder, we refer to the deterioration of urban landscapes, for example, graffiti on buildings, abandoned cars, broken windows, and garbage in the streets.Visible evidence of disorder, or what Albert Hunter (1985) calls "incivilities," have long been noted as central to a neighborhood's public presentation (Goffman 1963).Jane Jacobs's classic observation of urban life in the 1950s even then evoked a concern with the threats of disorder to neighborhood civility (1961, pp.29-54), especially the negotiation of public encounters in the "world of strangers" (Lofland 1973). 2 The streets, parks, and sidewalks still belong to no one and therefore to everyone.Disorder continues to be of theoretical interest precisely because of its visual salience and symbolism regarding the use of such spaces.Even if we wish it were not so, disorder triggers attributions and predictions in the minds of insiders and outsiders alike.It changes the calculus of prospective home buyers, real estate agents, insurance agents, and investors and shapes the perceptions of residents who might be considering moving.Evidence of disorder also gives a running account of the effectiveness of residents seeking neighborhood improvement, and that record may encourage or discourage future activism.Physical and social disorder in public spaces are thus fundamental to a general understanding of urban neighborhoods.Neighborhood disorder has more specific bearing on the study of crime as well.Research has established connections between disorder and both fear of crime and crime rates (Skogan 1990;Kelling and Coles 1996).In fact, a reigning theory posits that minor disorder is a direct cause of serious crime.Originators of the "broken windows" thesis, Wilson and Kelling (1982) argued that public incivilities-even if relatively minor as in the case of broken windows, drinking in the street, and graffiti-attract predatory crime because potential offenders assume from them that residents are indifferent to what goes on in their neighborhood.The metaphor of observation provided the inspiration and practical guidance for our work, and the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences provided a most hospitable intellectual environment for its fruition.Data collection was funded in part by the
1
It offers a new empirical approach to examining disorder in neighborhoods through structured observation rather than relying solely on resident perceptions.
2
The paper focuses on public-space disorder as a measurable characteristic of urban neighborhoods, linking observational evidence to neighborhood-level analysis.
3
The study introduces systematic social observation as a method for measuring physical and social disorder in urban public spaces.

Public spaces in urban neighborhoods

Visible social and physical disorder and its spatial variation across urban neighborhoods

Publication Details
Publication Date
1999-11-01
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
2547
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Stephen W. Raudenbush
Robert J. Sampson
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%