Civic Participation in a Hybrid Regime: Limited Pluralism in Policymaking and Delivery in Contemporary Russia

Гражданское участие в гибридном режиме: ограниченный плюрализм в разработке и реализации политики в современной России
Eleanor Bindman, Catherine Owen
2017-06-06

civic participationhybrid regimelimited pluralismpublic policymakingsocially oriented NGOs
This article asks why the Russian government has developed new avenues for public participation in policymaking and delivery and assesses the extent to which these avenues introduce pluralism into these processes. Drawing on 50 interviews with individuals and citizens’ groups involved in either public consultative bodies or socially oriented NGOs, the article demonstrates the government’s desire to harness the knowledge and abilities of citizens and civic groups in place of state departments perceived to be bureaucratic and inefficient, while controlling and curtailing their participation. Arguing that these countervailing tendencies can be conceptualized as limited pluralism, a category elaborated by Juan Linz and Alfred Stepan, we show that citizens and civic groups are able to influence policy outcomes to varying extents using these mechanisms.
1
Based on 50 interviews, citizens and civic groups are shown to influence policy outcomes, although their influence varies across mechanisms and cases.
2
The Russian government created new participation channels to harness citizens’ and civic groups’ knowledge and capabilities in response to bureaucratic and inefficient state departments.
3
The article conceptualizes this combination of inclusion and constraint as “limited pluralism” in contemporary Russian policymaking and service delivery.
4
These participation mechanisms expand civic involvement while simultaneously controlling and restricting the scope of citizen and civil-society participation.

Public participation mechanisms (public consultative bodies and socially oriented NGOs) in Russian policymaking and service delivery

The extent and mechanisms of limited pluralism, including the influence of citizen and civic-group participation on policy outcomes under government control and constraint

Publication Details
Publication Date
2017-06-06
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
61
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Eleanor Bindman
Catherine Owen
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%