The critiques and criticisms of positive psychology: a systematic review

Критика и критические замечания в адрес позитивной психологии: систематический обзор
Stewart I. Donaldson, Bryan J. Dik, Llewellyn Ellardus van Zyl, Jaclyn Gaffaney, Leoni van der Vaart
2023-02-23

content analysisneoliberalist ideologypositive psychologyreplicationsystematic literature review
The purpose of this systematic literature review was to explore the current critiques and criticisms of positive psychology and to provide a consolidated view of the main challenges facing the third wave of research.The review identified 32 records that posed 117 unique criticisms and critiques of various areas of the discipline.These could be grouped into 21 categories through conventional content analysis, culminating in six overarching themes or 'broad criticisms/critiques'.The findings suggested that positive psychology (a) lacked proper theorizing and conceptual thinking, (b) was problematic as far as measurement and methodologies were concerned, (c) was seen as a pseudoscience that lacked evidence and had poor replication, (d) lacked novelty and self-isolated itself from mainstream psychology, (e) was a decontextualized neoliberalist ideology that caused harm, and (f) was a capitalistic venture.We briefly reflect on the findings and highlight the opportunities these criticisms and critiques present.
1
A systematic review identified 32 records containing 117 unique criticisms of positive psychology.
2
Content analysis organized the criticisms into 21 categories and six overarching themes.
3
Critics argued that positive psychology lacks adequate theorizing and conceptual thinking.
4
Critics characterized positive psychology as lacking novelty, isolated from mainstream psychology, decontextualized and potentially harmful, neoliberalist, and capitalistic.
5
Measurement and methodological problems, weak evidence, and poor replication were identified as major concerns, including accusations of pseudoscience.

Positive psychology (the discipline)

the current critiques, criticisms, and challenges concerning its theorizing, conceptualization, measurement, methodology, evidential basis, replication, novelty, contextualization, ideological effects, and commercialization

Publication Details
Publication Date
2023-02-23
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
283
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Stewart I. Donaldson
Bryan J. Dik
Llewellyn Ellardus van Zyl
Jaclyn Gaffaney
Leoni van der Vaart
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%