Assessing the performance of emerging and existing continuous monitoring solutions under a single-blind controlled testing protocol
Оценка эффективности новых и существующих решений для непрерывного мониторинга в рамках протокола контролируемых испытаний с ослеплением одной стороны
2025-09-29
SCID: 54.1/p9pvdppa
Discuss with AI
continuous monitoringfalse positive and false negative ratesmethane emissionsmethod detection limitsingle-blind controlled testing
Figures from the paper
Abstract (AI)
Continuous monitoring (CM) solutions can facilitate faster detection and repair of emissions compared to traditional survey methods. This study tested 13 CM solutions over 12 weeks using single-blind controlled testing. Controlled release rates ranged from 0.08 to 6.75 kg CH4 h−1 and lasted 18 min to 8 h. Six solutions demonstrated 90% method detection limits (DL90s) ranging from 0.5 [0.3, 0.6] kg CH4 h−1 to 6.7 [5.9, 8.0] kg CH4 h−1. Of the 6 solutions, 5 had low False Positive (FP) rates (7.8%–18.9%), and 4 had low False Negative (FN) rates (8.0%–34.1%). Similar to Ilonze et al., the results show that the tested solutions balance method sensitivity with low FP and FN rates. All scanning/imaging solutions achieved high localization precision and accuracy (≥40%) at the equipment unit level. Single quantification estimates exhibited high relative quantification errors, ranging from 33 [0.9, 66]%, 95% confidence interval (CI) to 1326 [1003, 1648]%, 95% CI for small emissions (between 0.1 and 1 kg CH4 h−1) and from 3 [−20, 26]%, 95% CI to 3578 [−2832, 9988]%, 95% CI for large emissions (>1 kg CH4 h−1). The mean detection time for all solutions ranged from 5 h to 5 days. Relative to previous studies, errors in quantification estimates decreased, as did FN and FP rates, with improved DL90s for 2 of the 4 retested solutions. However, the mean detection times increased for 2 solutions, remained constant for one solution, and decreased for 1 of the 4 retested solutions. These findings highlight that continuous, rigorous testing enhances solution performance, with notable improvements observed across multiple testing programs using the same test protocol.
Key Findings
1
Among the six solutions, five had low false-positive rates of 7.8%–18.9%, while four had low false-negative rates of 8.0%–34.1%.
2
Mean detection times ranged from 5 hours to 5 days; repeated testing generally reduced quantification, false-positive, and false-negative errors, although detection-time improvements were inconsistent.
3
Scanning and imaging solutions achieved at least 40% localization precision and accuracy at the equipment-unit level.
4
Single-event quantification showed highly variable relative errors, ranging from 33% to 1326% for small emissions and 3% to 3578% for large emissions.
5
Six solutions achieved 90% detection limits ranging from 0.5 [0.3, 0.6] to 6.7 [5.9, 8.0] kg CH4 h−1.
6
Thirteen continuous monitoring solutions were evaluated over 12 weeks using a single-blind controlled-testing protocol with methane releases of 0.08–6.75 kg CH4 h−1.
Research Object
13 continuous monitoring (CM) solutions for methane emissions
Research Subject
Detection, localization, quantification, false-positive and false-negative performance, and detection time under single-blind controlled release testing
Publication Details
Publication Date
2025-09-29
Journal
Elementa Science of the Anthropocene
Publisher
BioOne
ISSN
2325-1026
Cited by
12
Open access PDF
Access Type
Author Information
Download PDF
Subscribe to digest
References available in scid.ai3
Comparing Continuous Methane Monitoring Technologies for High-Volume Emissions: A Single-Blind Controlled Release Study2024
Assessing the Progress of the Performance of Continuous Monitoring Solutions under a Single-Blind Controlled Testing Protocol2024
Point Sensor Networks Struggle to Detect and Quantify Short Controlled Releases at Oil and Gas Sites2024