Comparing Continuous Methane Monitoring Technologies for High-Volume Emissions: A Single-Blind Controlled Release Study

Сравнение технологий непрерывного мониторинга метана при крупных выбросах: исследование с контролируемыми выбросами и одиночным слепым контролем
Adam R. Brandt, Sahar H. El Abbadi, Evan David Sherwin, Zhenlin Chen, Philippine M. Burdeau, Jeffrey S. Rutherford, Yuanlei Chen, Zhan Zhang
2024-06-04

continuous methane monitoringcontrolled release testingfalse positive ratehigh-volume methane emissionsoil and gas operations
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide Methane emissions from oil and gas operations are a primary concern for climate change mitigation. While traditional methane detection relies on periodic surveys that yield episodic data, continuous monitoring solutions promise to offer consistent insights and a richer understanding of emission inventories. Despite this promise, the detection and quantification abilities of continuous monitoring solutions remain unclear. To address this uncertainty, our study comprehensively assessed 8 commercial continuous monitoring solutions using controlled release tests to simulate high-volume venting (e.g., uncontrolled tanks, pneumatics, and unlit flares), which accounts for a significant fraction of total emissions from oil and gas systems. The performance of each team varied: when comparing reported results on a second-by-second basis, all teams reported false positive rates below 10%. For true positive rates, 4 out of 8 systems exceed 80%. In the field test where continuous monitoring solutions identified and reported an emission event, all systems’ reliability of identification surpassed 70%. When systems reported that there was no emission event, the reliability of nonemission identification varied from 29.4% to 96.2%. Among 5 systems tested for quantifying the daily average emission rate released by the Stanford team, all were underestimated by an average of 74.38% emissions. This indicates that their application in emissions reporting or regulation may be premature. The variability in monitor performance underscores the importance of understanding systems’ strengths and limitations before their broader adoption in methane mitigation approaches or regulatory frameworks.
1
All systems reported second-by-second false-positive rates below 10%, while only four of eight achieved true-positive rates exceeding 80%.
2
Five systems underestimated daily average emission rates by an average of 74.38%, suggesting regulatory or reporting use may be premature.
3
Reliability of identifying nonemission events varied substantially, ranging from 29.4% to 96.2% across systems.
4
The study evaluated eight commercial continuous methane-monitoring systems using controlled releases simulating high-volume oil and gas emissions.
5
When systems identified an emission event, identification reliability exceeded 70% for every tested system.

Commercial continuous methane monitoring solutions applied to high-volume methane releases from oil and gas operations

Detection, identification reliability, false-positive and true-positive rates, and emission-rate quantification accuracy of continuous methane monitoring solutions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-06-04
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
39
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Adam R. Brandt
Sahar H. El Abbadi
Evan David Sherwin
Zhenlin Chen
Philippine M. Burdeau
Jeffrey S. Rutherford
Yuanlei Chen
Zhan Zhang
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%