Assessing the Progress of the Performance of Continuous Monitoring Solutions under a Single-Blind Controlled Testing Protocol

Оценка прогресса в повышении эффективности систем непрерывного мониторинга в рамках протокола контролируемых испытаний с однократным ослеплением
Daniel J. Zimmerle, Ethan Emerson, Chiemezie Ilonze, Aidan Duggan
2024-06-12

continuous monitoring solutionsfalse positive ratesmethane emissionsmethod detection limitssingle-blind controlled testing
High Resolution Image Download MS PowerPoint Slide The recent regulatory spotlight on continuous monitoring (CM) solutions and the rapid development of CM solutions have demanded the characterization of solution performance through regular, rigorous testing using consensus test protocols. This study is the second known implementation of such a protocol involving single-blind controlled testing of 9 CM solutions. Controlled releases of rates (6–7100 g) CH 4 /h over durations (0.4–10.2 h) under a wind speed range of (0.7–9.9 m/s) were conducted for 11 weeks. Results showed that 4 solutions achieved method detection limits (DL90s) within the tested emission rate range, with all 4 solutions having both the lowest DL90s (3.9 [3.0, 5.5] kg CH 4 /h to 6.2 [3.7, 16.7] kg CH 4 /h) and false positive rates (6.9–13.2%), indicating efforts at balancing low sensitivity with a low false positive rate. These results are likely best-case scenario estimates since the test center represents a near-ideal upstream field natural gas operation condition. Quantification results showed wide individual estimate uncertainties, with emissions underestimation and overestimation by factors up to >14 and 42, respectively. Three solutions had >80% of their estimates within a quantification factor of 3 for controlled releases in the ranges of [0.1–1] kg CH 4 /h and > 1 kg CH 4 /h. Relative to the study by Bell et al., current solutions performance, as a group, generally improved, primarily due to solutions from the study by Bell et al. that were retested. This result highlights the importance of regular quality testing to the advancement of CM solutions for effective emissions mitigation.
1
A single-blind controlled protocol evaluated nine continuous methane-monitoring solutions using releases of 6–7100 g CH₄/h over 11 weeks.
2
Four solutions achieved method detection limits within the tested range, with DL90s of 3.9–6.2 kg CH₄/h and false-positive rates of 6.9–13.2%.
3
Overall performance generally improved relative to the Bell et al. study, emphasizing the importance of regular quality testing for advancing continuous-monitoring solutions.
4
Quantification estimates showed substantial uncertainty, with underestimation by factors up to greater than 14 and overestimation by factors up to 42.
5
Three solutions placed more than 80% of estimates within a factor of three for controlled releases spanning 0.1–1 kg CH₄/h and above 1 kg CH₄/h.

Continuous methane monitoring solutions tested under single-blind controlled releases at an upstream natural gas operation

Detection, false-positive rates, and emission-quantification performance of continuous monitoring solutions across controlled methane release rates and wind conditions

Publication Details
Publication Date
2024-06-12
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
35
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Daniel J. Zimmerle
Ethan Emerson
Chiemezie Ilonze
Aidan Duggan
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%