Moral Responsibility and Determinism: The Cognitive Science of Folk Intuitions

Моральная ответственность и детерминизм: когнитивная наука о народных интуициях
Joshua Knobe, Shaun Nichols
2007-10-25

affect / emotional influence on moral judgmentcompatibilism vs incompatibilismdeterminismfolk intuitionsmoral responsibility
The dispute between compatibilists and incompatibilists must be one of the most persistent and heated deadlocks in Western philosophy. Incompatibilists maintain that people are not fully morally responsible if determinism is true, i.e., if every event is an inevitable consequence of the prior conditions and the natural laws. By contrast, compatibilists maintain
1
Different psychological processes (affective vs. deliberative) generate distinct folk intuitions about responsibility and determinism.
2
Emotional/affect-triggering scenarios shift judgments toward compatibilist attributions of full moral responsibility.
3
Experimental data show responses vary dramatically with question framing: abstract prompts yield incompatibilist answers, emotional prompts yield compatibilist answers.
4
People possess an underlying incompatibilist theory of moral responsibility when prompted by abstract, theoretical questions.
5
The role of affect in producing compatibilist intuitions raises questions about which intuitions reliably track the true relation between determinism and moral responsibility.

Folk intuitions about moral responsibility (people's intuitive judgments about moral responsibility under scenarios involving determinism and affect)

How psychological processes—particularly affective (emotional) versus abstract/theoretical cognition—influence whether people's intuitions align with incompatibilism or compatibilism about moral responsibility under deterministic scenarios

Publication Details
Publication Date
2007-10-25
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
717
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Joshua Knobe
Shaun Nichols
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%