Understanding deposition rate loss in high power impulse magnetron sputtering: I. Ionization-driven electric fields

Понимание снижения скорости осаждения при импульсном магнетронном распылении высокой мощности: I. Электрические поля, обусловленные ионизацией
Ulf Helmersson, Daniel Lundin, Tiberiu M Minea, Chunqing Huo, Michael A. Raadu, N. Brenning, Cătălin Vițelaru, Gabi-Daniel Stancu
2012-03-09

HiPIMSTownsend productback-attraction of sputtered ionsion transport to substrateionization-driven electric fields
The lower deposition rate for high power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) compared with direct current magnetron sputtering for the same average power is often reported as a drawback. The often invoked reason is back-attraction of ionized sputtered material to the target due to a substantial negative potential profile, sometimes called an extended presheath, from the location of ionization toward the cathode. Recent studies in HiPIMS devices, using floating-emitting and swept-Langmuir probes, show that such extended potential profiles do exist, and that the electric fields E-z directed toward the target can be strong enough to seriously reduce ion transport to the substrate. However, they also show that the potential drops involved can vary by up to an order of magnitude from case to case. There is a clear need to understand the underlying mechanisms and identify the key discharge variables that can be used for minimizing the back-attraction. We here present a combined theoretical and experimental analysis of the problem of electric fields E-z in the ionization region part of HiPIMS discharges, and their effect on the transport of ionized sputtered material. In particular, we have investigated the possibility of a sweet spot in parameter space in which the back-attraction of ionized sputtered material is low. It is concluded that a sweet spot might possibly exist for some carefully optimized discharges, but probably in a rather narrow window of parameters. As a measure of how far a discharge is from such a window, a Townsend product Pi(Townsend) is proposed. A parametric analysis of Pi(Townsend) shows that the search for a sweet spot is complicated by the fact that contradictory demands appear for several of the externally controllable parameters such as high/low working gas pressure, short/long pulse length, high/low pulse power and high/low magnetic field strength.
1
A low-back-attraction sweet spot may exist, but likely only within a narrow range of carefully optimized discharge parameters.
2
Experiments confirm extended negative potential profiles and target-directed electric fields in the HiPIMS ionization region, which can strongly reduce ion transport to the substrate.
3
HiPIMS exhibits lower deposition rates than DC magnetron sputtering at equal average power, partly because ionized sputtered material is attracted back toward the negatively biased target.
4
Potential drops vary by up to an order of magnitude between operating conditions, indicating that discharge parameters critically control back-attraction strength.
5
The proposed Townsend product provides a measure of proximity to this sweet spot, but optimization is difficult because pressure, pulse length, pulse power, and magnetic-field strength impose conflicting requirements.

ionization-region electric fields and ionized sputtered-material transport in high-power impulse magnetron sputtering (HiPIMS) discharges

the mechanisms and discharge-parameter dependence of back-attraction of ionized sputtered material to the target, including the conditions for minimizing it

Publication Details
Publication Date
2012-03-09
Journal
Publisher
ISSN
Cited by
87
Access Type
Author Information
Authors
Ulf Helmersson
Daniel Lundin
Tiberiu M Minea
Chunqing Huo
Michael A. Raadu
N. Brenning
Cătălin Vițelaru
Gabi-Daniel Stancu
Explore further
Open the scid.ai AI chat with a ready-made request: it will find papers on a similar topic and help build a literature review.
Find similar papers in the chat →
Make a presentation
100%